Stuff I Don't Understand...

Discussion of the nature of Ultimate Reality and the path to Enlightenment.
Locked
TheSourceCode

Stuff I Don't Understand...

Post by TheSourceCode »

Diogenes was once asked what he thought of Socrates. "A madman," he replied.

Later, Plato was asked what he thought of Diogenes. "A Socrates gone mad," he replied.

Diogenes ridiculed Plato for being long-winded.
That doesn't make much sense.
TheSourceCode

Re: Stuff I Don't Understand...

Post by TheSourceCode »

I am eagerly awaiting the appearance of some dimwit of a monk (or barring that, half such a monk) richly endowed with a natural stock of spiritual power and kindled within by a raging religious fire, who will fling himself unhesitatingly into the midst of this poison and instantly die the Great Death.

Rising from that Death, he will arm himself with a calabash of gigantic size and roam the great earth seeking true and genuine monks. Wherever he encounters one, he will spit in his fists, flex his muscles, fill his calabash with deadly poison and fling a dipperful of it over him, drenching him head to foot, so that he too is forced to surrender his life. Ah! what a magnificent sight to behold!
Also, can you please explain the meaning of this.
TheSourceCode

Re: Stuff I Don't Understand...

Post by TheSourceCode »

Ugh.
User avatar
Dan Rowden
Posts: 5740
Joined: Sun Sep 09, 2001 8:03 pm
Contact:

Re: Stuff I Don't Understand...

Post by Dan Rowden »

TheSourceCode wrote:
Diogenes was once asked what he thought of Socrates. "A madman," he replied.

Later, Plato was asked what he thought of Diogenes. "A Socrates gone mad," he replied.

Diogenes ridiculed Plato for being long-winded.
That doesn't make much sense.
I think Diogenes was simply making a point about economy of language. i.e. don't use more words to make your point that you need to. Either that or Diogenes was just being a smartarse.
Steven Coyle

Re: Stuff I Don't Understand...

Post by Steven Coyle »

You could also look at it from the angle of Diogene's sense of self. Diogenes, like Socrates, required a very strong sense of purpose in order to manage the philosophic life he once led. In his rebuttal to Plato's remark, Diogenes is also saying, "I like Socrates. I understand Socrates. He's an outlaw, much like myself."
ataxas
Posts: 66
Joined: Sun Nov 25, 2007 4:10 pm

Re: Stuff I Don't Understand...

Post by ataxas »

Diogenes was making a joke, and a statement about language. If Socrates is a madman, as Diogenes said, and if Diogenes is a Socrates gone mad, as Plato said, then Diogenes is a madman gone mad, which is redundant.
User avatar
Jamesh
Posts: 1526
Joined: Fri Jul 22, 2005 3:44 pm

Re: Stuff I Don't Understand...

Post by Jamesh »

Proabably just a play on words.


I know stuff all about either Diogenes or Socrates, but I would speculate he was pointing to the different forms of madness. The impression I get of Socrates is that he was a lover of life, he was a people person, to the point of madness, whereas Diogenes hated life, particularly humans. That Socrates could have avoided his death means nothing - he was old and had had enough.

The first form is tolerable madness, madness one can appreciate, the persons volatilty is kind of fun, the second form is far more insane, truly crazy. That Diogenes the Dog hated humanity, yet still whined about it, meant that he actually wanted humanity to survive, he whined to induce improvement, so there was a core conflict of rationality, a madness, in his beliefs.
Ataraxia
Posts: 594
Joined: Tue May 15, 2007 11:41 pm
Location: Melbourne

Re: Stuff I Don't Understand...

Post by Ataraxia »

I never got the impression that Diogenes hated life.Rather he was a cynic and considered himself surrounded by fools.

Fair play to him.
xerox

Re: Stuff I Don't Understand...

Post by xerox »

...
Locked